Chapter 3 - The House I Left in the Night
|
I did not sleep that first night back at the Caruso estate.
Alessandro gave me the same guest room I had used during our marriage, at the far end of the east hall.
The bed was larger than my entire rented room in Bellhaven.
The sheets smelled like lavender and clean rain.
A woman from the household staff left folded clothes on the dresser and told me they had belonged to me once.
I recognized a blue sweater I had worn the winter I turned nineteen.
Someone had kept my things for four years.
Someone had washed them, folded them, and waited as if I might walk through the door any day.
I sat on the edge of the bed with my stitched hand in my lap and stared at the dark garden below.
At eighteen, I had thought this house was a beautiful prison built to remind me that my life was no longer mine.
At twenty-four, I understood that a prison would not have kept my sweater.
In the morning, I walked the hallways alone while Alessandro spoke with Dante behind a closed door.
Every room brought back a memory I had tried to bury under double shifts and unpaid bills.
The dining room still had the long mahogany table where I had eaten silent dinners across from a husband I barely knew.
The library door still stuck a little when I pulled it open.
The morning room still caught the first light over the wet lawn.
On my wedding day, I had stood in that morning room in a white dress that cost more than my father's first truck.
Aunt Marie had pinned my veil with shaking hands and told me to be grateful.
My father had been dead for less than two weeks.
His funeral flowers had still been fresh in the cemetery across town.
Alessandro had waited for me at the front of the chapel with a face carved from stone.
I had thought he looked like a man facing a firing squad instead of a bride.
For six years, I had carried that look as proof that he hated me for being forced into his life.
Last night, in the kitchen, he had told me something I could not stop hearing.
He had buried his own father Antonio only three months before our wedding.
Antonio had been sick, but Alessandro had believed there would be more time.
Instead, Alessandro had stood in that chapel grieving two men, his father and my father, while strangers watched him marry a frightened girl.
His cold face had not been hatred for me.
It had been grief he was too proud and too young to show anyone.
At twenty-six, he had already been taught that a Caruso heir never wept in public.
I walked into the library and ran my good hand along the shelves.
This room had been the only place in the house where I had ever felt almost safe.
During our marriage, books had begun appearing on the small table beside my favorite chair.
A novel about a woman who sailed around the world alone appeared the week after I mentioned the sea at dinner.
A history of women artists appeared after I admitted I had once wanted to study painting.
A thick atlas appeared with a ribbon marking the small towns of Italy my mother had come from.
Alessandro had never handed me a single one of those books himself.
He had left them without a note, as if kindness embarrassed him.
At nineteen, I had convinced myself that a kind housekeeper must have been responsible.
Now I saw his handwriting on an old checkout card tucked inside the atlas, and my chest ached.
He had also paid for a tutor when I told Mrs. Moretti that I had dropped out of my business classes to save money.
The tutor, a patient woman named Miss Alvarez, had come twice a week for a year and never once mentioned who paid her.
I had earned top marks in accounting under her guidance.
I had used those lessons to keep Aunt Marie's household budget alive on my bakery wages.
We had slept in separate rooms for the entire two years of our marriage.
At first, I had been relieved and then quietly humiliated by that distance.
Other wives at family dinners had whispered about heirs and duty while looking at my empty ring finger.
I had kept the plain silver wedding ring Alessandro gave me, but I had worn it on a chain under my clothes even then.
I wore it there still, cold against my skin beneath my borrowed sweater.
Last night, Alessandro had finally explained the separate rooms in plain words.
He told me he had refused to share a bed with a grieving eighteen-year-old who had not truly chosen him.
He told me a forced marriage bed would have made him exactly the kind of man his uncle said he was.
I had stared at him across that kitchen table and not known what to say.
The man I remembered as cold had been trying, clumsily and silently, not to frighten me.
A soft knock pulled me out of the library and into the hallway.
Dante stood outside a closed door I had never entered during our marriage.
"Boss asked me to show you this when you were ready."
"Show me what?"
"The study."
Alessandro's private study smelled like leather, paper, and the cedar polish the staff used on his desk.
One entire wall stopped me in the doorway.
Photographs covered it from the wainscoting to the crown molding.
Printed maps of Pittsburgh, Cleveland, and Bellhaven were pinned side by side with red string stretched between them.
Investigator reports were stacked in labeled folders beneath dated photographs of bus stations, apartment buildings, and bakery storefronts.
A framed photograph of me at nineteen sat crooked beside a security still of me at twenty-three, carrying groceries through snow in Cleveland.
I had never known that photograph existed.
I had never felt him anywhere near that snowy street.
Dante left me alone without another word.
I stepped closer and read the careful notes written beneath each map.
Missed by six hours, one note said under a Pittsburgh address I remembered too well.
Landlord confirmed two women left before dawn, another note said.
Marie Chen seen with an unidentified man in a silver sedan, a third note said.
Four years of searching had been pinned to this wall, one failure at a time.
Alessandro appeared in the doorway behind me.
"I did not want you to see it like this."
"Like what?"
"Like proof that I was too slow."
"You searched for me in three cities."
"I searched for you in eleven cities."
"The wall only shows the places where we were close."
I touched the edge of the Bellhaven map, where a red circle marked Moretti's Bakery.
"When did you find me here?"
"Three weeks ago."
"Three weeks?"
"A debt report on Marie came through a collection network my men monitor."
"Nico Ferraro filed an updated address for her, and your name was listed as the emergency contact at the bakery."
My bruised wrist throbbed at the mention of Nico Ferraro.
"He grabbed me outside the bakery last week and told me we owed eighty-seven thousand dollars."
Alessandro's gray eyes darkened at the number.
"He will not touch you again."
"Why did you wait three weeks if you knew where I was?"
"Because the last two times we moved too fast, Marie vanished with you before sunrise."
"I needed to know who was watching the bakery besides us."
"I needed a safe way to approach you that would not lead your father's killers straight to your door."
"You still led them there."
"No, Sophia."
"They were already watching that bakery before I ever sat down inside it."
I looked again at the photograph of me in the Cleveland snow.
"You watched me from a distance."
"Yes."
"For three weeks, you watched me work and said nothing."
"I said nothing because the first time you saw me, I wanted it to be your choice whether to run."
His honesty hurt more than a lie would have.
A lie would have let me stay angry.
I turned away from the wall because I could not look at four years of effort and keep calling it abandonment.
"Why did you never simply come in for coffee and tell me the truth like a normal person?"
Alessandro was quiet for so long that I thought he would not answer.
Then he stepped beside me and pointed to the corner of the Bellhaven map, where a small photograph showed the bakery window table.
"I did come in for coffee."
"Every morning for three weeks, I sat at the corner table with a newspaper I never read."
May you like
"You carried trays past me a dozen times a day."
"And you never once looked up."
