Chapter 5 - What Aunt Marie Never Told Me
|
Dante brought Aunt Marie to the Caruso estate the next morning under a plain gray sky.
She arrived in the back of an unmarked car with a carpetbag on her knees and fear written all over her face.
She was fifty-eight years old, but in the estate driveway she looked ten years older.
Her coat was buttoned wrong.
Her hands shook so badly that she dropped her bag on the wet stone.
I picked it up for her because old habits are stronger than anger.
She stared at me as if she expected me to slap her.
"Sophia, I thought they had killed you at that bakery."
"No, Marie."
"Alessandro saved me at that bakery."
She flinched at the way I said his name, without fear and without a title.
Alessandro waited on the front steps and did not approach her until I nodded.
"You will be safe in this house," he told her.
"You will also tell the truth in this house."
Marie sat in the morning room with a cup of tea she never drank and finally, after four years of lies, began at the beginning.
"It started with eighteen thousand dollars."
"I owed eighteen thousand dollars to a card room behind the old theater in downtown Bellhaven."
"I borrowed it after your father died because I was grieving and stupid and convinced I could win back his funeral costs."
I closed my eyes because I had paid those funeral costs myself from my father's small life insurance payment.
She had gambled while I counted coins for his headstone.
"The men who held the debt sold it within a month."
"Lorenzo's men bought it and came to my door with new papers."
"They said interest and penalties brought the total to eighty-seven thousand dollars."
"Eighty-seven thousand dollars for a debt that began at eighteen thousand."
"They said if I did not pay, they would take the house and hurt you."
Nico Ferraro had been the face of that threat from the very first visit.
She described how Nico smiled while he listed my school, my shifts, and later my bakery schedule.
She described how Nico grabbed my wrist outside the bakery last week, a bruise Alessandro had seen within minutes of finding me.
That grab had not been a random act of cruelty.
Nico worked for Lorenzo, and every threat he delivered had been Lorenzo's words in a younger man's mouth.
"Then Lorenzo came to me himself, about a month before you disappeared from the estate."
"He sat in my kitchen and told me Alessandro planned to kill you on your twenty-fifth birthday."
"He said the Chen Trust would fall to Alessandro once you were dead and out of the way."
"He said your marriage had only ever been a way to keep you close until you were old enough for the trust to pay out."
I looked across the room at Alessandro, who stood by the window with his hands locked behind his back.
Henry Whitaker, my father's lawyer and the trustee of the Chen Family Trust, had already confirmed the truth to us by phone that morning.
The trust held forty-nine percent of Chen Logistics and the Bellhaven Terminal 4 lease.
I was its sole beneficiary.
On my twenty-fifth birthday, in eleven days, I would gain voting control of that trust.
Alessandro gained nothing from the trust, not a share, not a dollar, and not a single vote.
If I died or signed a transfer before I turned twenty-five, control would pass instead to the alternate trustee named in my father's papers.
That alternate trustee was Lorenzo Caruso.
Lorenzo had not been warning Marie about Alessandro at all.
Lorenzo had been describing his own plan and putting Alessandro's face on it.
Marie wiped her face with a tissue and kept talking, as if stopping would kill her.
"Lorenzo offered to save us both."
"He said if I took you away quietly and kept you moving, he would hold the debt collectors off and keep Alessandro away from you."
"We went to Pittsburgh first, to a cousin of a woman I knew from the card room."
"When his investigators got close, Lorenzo's driver moved us to Cleveland in the middle of the night."
"In Bellhaven, I told myself we were finally far enough away to stop running."
"We were never far enough, because Lorenzo always knew exactly where we were."
"He called every month."
"Some months he sent money for rent in an envelope with no return address."
"Some months he sent Nico instead, just to remind me what would happen if I ever contacted the Caruso family."
I thought of every cramped apartment and every job I had quit without saying goodbye.
I thought of the night classes I had abandoned in Pittsburgh and the friend in Cleveland whose calls I had never returned.
Four years of my life had been arranged by a man smiling at a dinner table.
Marie reached into her carpetbag and pulled out a worn shoebox tied with kitchen string.
"I kept these."
"God forgive me, Sophia, I kept them and never showed you."
Inside the shoebox were unopened letters in Alessandro's handwriting, addressed to me at apartments I barely remembered.
Beneath the letters were business cards from private investigators who had knocked on our doors in Pittsburgh and Cleveland.
Beneath the cards were printed warnings Marie had received, each one reminding her that men were still asking for Sophia by name.
One card bore Dante's name and a phone number I could have called at any time.
One letter, still sealed, was dated only three months after I vanished.
I held proof in my hands that Alessandro had never stopped looking and that Marie had hidden that proof from me for years.
Down the hall, a door closed hard enough to make Marie jump.
Dante appeared in the doorway a moment later with a grim expression.
"We have Nico Ferraro in the service garage."
"He came to Marie's Bellhaven apartment an hour ago looking for her."
"He was carrying her updated shift schedule for your bakery and a burner phone with Lorenzo's private number in it."
Alessandro finally turned from the window.
"Bring Whitaker here before anyone speaks to Nico about money."
Within the hour, Henry Whitaker sat in the morning room with the original debt papers spread across the low table.
He separated Lorenzo's inflated charges from the verified original debt with a red pen and a lawyer's disgust.
"The original eighteen thousand dollars is documented and lawful to settle."
"The remaining sixty-nine thousand dollars rests on forged fees and threats that will not survive a courtroom."
Alessandro did not bargain and did not posture.
He instructed Whitaker to pay only the verified original eighteen thousand dollars, through the trust office, with a full written release.
Not one dollar would be paid for the threats.
Not one dollar would reward Lorenzo's men for four years of fear.
Marie watched the papers being signed and began to cry in earnest.
"I am so sorry, Sophia."
"I was a coward and a gambler and a fool, and I let that man use all three against you."
"Please forgive me."
I looked at my aunt, my father's sister, the woman who had raised me after he died and then handed me over to a lie.
I could not give her the words she wanted.
"Not yet, Marie."
"I do not know if I can forgive you yet."
"But I will not let Alessandro throw you out of this house to face Lorenzo alone."
"You will stay here, and you will answer every question Whitaker and Dante ask you."
She nodded and clutched her tissue like a lifeline.
Alessandro said nothing, but he gave a single order to the household staff to prepare the room beside mine for her.
That small obedience to my decision, in his own house, steadied me more than any apology could have.
Marie suddenly grabbed my uninjured hand with a strength that startled me.
"There is one more thing."
"One more thing I should have told you the moment I walked in."
"Lorenzo called me yesterday."
"He called me yesterday afternoon, before the shooting, and he knew your bakery shift down to the hour."
"He knew you would be carrying coffee to the front tables that morning."
My blood went cold in a way the gunfire had never managed.
"What did he say, Marie?"
May you like
She looked past me to Alessandro, and her voice dropped to a whisper I will hear in my sleep for the rest of my life.
"He said eleven days is a long time for accidents."
